Evaluate the following:
1. Does the essay respond to the question asked by the essay assignment?
2. Evaluate the author’s thesis. How can it be improved?
3. Evaluate body paragraphs. Are the topic sentences clear? Do we need to add more support? Are they well developed, coherent, and unified?
4. Evaluate the conclusion. Is it well developed? Was the thesis restated?
5. Any other suggestions to improve the paper?